A UPSC question once named three men and their groups, and asked which pairs were right. Most test-takers got one pair wrong. Before Congress ever met in 1885, at least eight separate groups were already writing petitions, holding meetings, and training the leaders who would later fill Congress halls.
Political association: A group that puts public demands to a government, usually through petitions and meetings.
Petition: A written, signed request asking rulers to act. It let leaders be heard, but gave them no vote over the final choice.
1.Why did Bengal end up with two rival groups before Congress?
1.1What did the Landholders’ Society and the Bengal British India Society each want?
- In 1837, the Landholders’ Society formed in Bengal to defend the interests of landowners across Bengal, Bihar, and Orissa.
- In 1843, a second group appeared: the Bengal British India Society. It aimed at wider public reforms, not just landowners’ concerns.
- The two groups worked side by side for years, each writing its own petitions to British rulers, before they ever joined forces.
1.2Why did Surendranath Banerjee build a second Calcutta group in 1876?
- Parliament was reviewing the East India Company’s charter in the early 1850s. That review gave Bengal’s two groups a reason to speak with one voice.
- In 1851, the Landholders’ Society and the Bengal British India Society merged into the British Indian Association in Calcutta. Radhakanta Deb became its first president.
- This new body still leaned on its landowner roots. By 1876, Surendranath Banerjee and Ananda Mohan Bose felt Bengal needed a different kind of group, one that spoke for students and young professionals. They built the Indian Association that same year.
- In 1883, the Indian Association called a National Conference, hoping to bring in activists from beyond Bengal. Exam trap: a “National” title did not mean the group truly spoke for all of India. Its own members still came from a narrow, educated slice of society.
True or false: The British Indian Association of 1851 grew out of two earlier Bengal groups, the Landholders’ Society and the Bengal British India Society.
2.How did Madras and London give Indian demands two very different audiences?
2.1What did the two Madras associations each stand for?
- In 1852, Gazulu Lakshminarasu Chetty founded the Madras Native Association. It sent petitions from the Madras Presidency straight to British lawmakers, raising complaints about Company rule and about the hardships facing farmers.
- Over 30 years later, in 1884, a separate body appeared: the Madras Mahajana Sabha, set up by P. Ananda Charlu and other public workers. It held meetings and built links across many districts. Charlu himself attended the first Congress session in 1885.
- Exam trap: these two Madras groups get mixed up often. Different founder, different year, thirty-two years apart — don’t let the shared city fool you.
2.2Why did Dadabhai Naoroji take India’s case all the way to London?
- In 1866, Dadabhai Naoroji helped start the East India Association in London. Its audience reached British politicians and the wider British public directly, not only readers back in India.
- London meetings gave Indian reformers a new stage to raise Indian issues, and Naoroji himself addressed the association in 1867.
- Date note: some later biographies give 1867 as the founding year, but the Congress’s own history traces the group’s start to 1866. Keep 1866 as the founding year unless a question specifically raises this dispute.
True or false: Gazulu Lakshminarasu Chetty founded the Madras Mahajana Sabha in 1884.
3.Why did Bombay and Poona need their own separate forums?
3.1What did the Bombay Association and the Bombay Presidency Association each do?
- The Bombay Association began in 1852. Like its Bengal and Madras counterparts, it used petitions during the debate over the Company’s charter.
- In January 1885, Pherozeshah Mehta, K. T. Telang, and Badruddin Tyabji founded the Bombay Presidency Association. A dispute over the Ilbert Bill, along with other colonial rules, had sharpened Bombay’s demand for a real political voice.
- Here’s why the date matters: this group formed a full eleven months before Congress first met. It was one of the last major pre-Congress associations, not an early one.
3.2What made the Poona Sarvajanik Sabha different from a city group?
- The Poona Sarvajanik Sabha began in 1870. M. G. Ranade, G. V. Joshi, and others helped build it into a public forum.
- Sarvajanik means public. The Sabha discussed how the government was run, and it sent petitions that claimed to speak for a wider population than just one city.
- These Bombay-region groups shared people and methods, and none of them simply vanished once Congress first met in December 1885.
True or false: The Bombay Presidency Association formed before the first Congress session.
4.Exam Angle: The Real Question on Matching These Associations to Their Founders
UPSC CSP 2017, GS Paper I, Q37
Listed three pairs: Radhakanta Deb with the British Indian Association, Gazulu Lakshminarasu Chetty with the Madras Mahajana Sabha, and Surendranath Banerjee with the Indian Association. Only the Deb and Banerjee pairs are right — Chetty founded the earlier Madras Native Association instead. The correct answer is 1 and 3 only.
Keep each city, year, founder, and group name tied together as one fact, not four loose ones. Similar names hiding different founders and different decades is the single most common trap across this whole topic.
MCQ on Political Associations Before the Indian National Congress
Question 1 of 1
Question 1 of 1
Question 1 of 1
Question 1 of 1
Question 1 of 1
Question 1 of 1
Question 1 of 1
Question 1 of 1
Related: The Indian National Congress: Founding and the Moderate-Extremist Phase · All Modern History Articles
Leave a Reply