Author: Alley · Updated: 2 Nov 2026 · Sources & corrections
Freedom on paper is not enough for a child whose family has no land and no school nearby. The framers knew this. Article 46 is their promise to such families. It does not give a right that a court can enforce. It gives the State a duty to act, and a reason to pass laws that do.
Directive Principle: a goal the State should follow when it makes laws and policy.
Weaker sections: groups that are socially, educationally or economically behind.
Non-justiciable: a court cannot order the State to obey it.
- \n
- What does Article 46 direct the State to do?
- Why is Article 46 only a directive?
- How do Articles 15(4) and 16(4) carry it out?
- Which laws and bodies give it effect?
- Does the Court treat directives as weak?
- How has this topic been asked in exams?
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
1What does Article 46 direct the State to do?
1.1 What are the two duties?
The first duty is to promote. The State must raise the educational and economic interests of weaker sections. Scholarships, hostels and loans are examples. The second duty is to protect. The State must shield these groups from social injustice and exploitation. Laws against atrocities and bonded labour are examples.
1.2 Why does it say “special care”?
The words “with special care” show urgency. The framers did not want a lukewarm effort. SCs and STs are named in particular. But the article also covers “other weaker sections”, so the State can widen its help to other groups that need it.
- Promote: education and economic interests.
- Protect: from social injustice and exploitation.
- Named: Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes.
- Also covers other weaker sections.
Remember This: Article 46 has two halves: promote their interests, and protect them from injustice and exploitation.
2Why is Article 46 only a directive?
2.1 What does Article 37 say?
Article 37 settles the matter. Directive Principles are not enforceable by any court. Yet they are “fundamental in the governance of the country”. It is the duty of the State to apply them when it makes laws. So a citizen cannot sue the State to force a scholarship scheme. But a law that follows Article 46 has a firm constitutional base.
2.2 What happened in Champakam Dorairajan?
In 1951, a Madras order reserved college seats by community. The Supreme Court struck it down in State of Madras v. Champakam Dorairajan. It held that Directive Principles cannot override a Fundamental Right. The order had clashed with Articles 15(1) and 29(2).
Parliament responded quickly. The First Amendment (1951) added Article 15(4). This let the State make special provisions for backward classes, and for SCs and STs.
- Article 37: Directive Principles cannot be enforced in court.
- Champakam 1951: a directive cannot override a Fundamental Right.
- First Amendment 1951: added Article 15(4).
True or False: A court can order the State to carry out Article 46.
3How do Articles 15(4) and 16(4) carry it out?
3.1 What is the link?
Think of Article 46 as the goal and Articles 15(4) and 16(4) as the tools. Article 15(4) allows special provisions in education. Article 16(4) allows reservation in public jobs. They are enabling provisions. They permit special measures but give no right to demand them. Measures taken under them can be challenged and defended in court. Article 46 itself cannot be enforced in court.
3.2 Why does the difference matter?
Exams love this contrast. All three articles aim at the same thing. But they work differently. Article 46 is a non-justiciable directive. Articles 15(4) and 16(4) are enabling provisions. The directive sets the aim. The Fundamental Rights provisions give the State the power to act.
| Article | Part | Role | Enforceable? |
|---|---|---|---|
| 46 | IV (Directive) | Duty to promote and protect weaker sections | No |
| 15(4) | III (Fundamental Rights) | Special provisions, such as in education | Enabling provision |
| 16(4) | III (Fundamental Rights) | Reservation in public employment | Enabling provision |
Remember This: Article 46 is the goal. Articles 15(4) and 16(4) are the tools that carry it out.
4Which laws and bodies give it effect?
4.1 What do the protection laws look like?
The Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 was passed because older laws were found too weak. It sets up Special Courts and provides relief for victims. It is the clearest example of the “protect” half of Article 46.
4.2 Which bodies watch over these groups?
The 89th Amendment (2003) split the old commission in two. It created separate National Commissions for Scheduled Castes (Article 338) and for Scheduled Tribes (Article 338A). The ST commission began work in February 2004. Each body checks how safeguards are working.

- 1989 Atrocities Act: criminal protection and Special Courts.
- Article 338: National Commission for Scheduled Castes.
- Article 338A: National Commission for Scheduled Tribes.
- Eklavya Model Residential Schools: education for tribal students.
Explain It Back: In your own words, say why Article 46 cannot be enforced in court. Then say which articles help the State act on it.
True or False: The 89th Amendment created separate National Commissions for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes.
5Does the Court treat directives as weak?
5.1 Are directives less important than rights?
Not quite. In Minerva Mills (1980), the Supreme Court said the Constitution rests on a balance between Fundamental Rights and Directive Principles. It struck down the 1976 attempt to give directives priority over rights. It held that this harmony is part of the basic structure.
5.2 What follows for Article 46?
Directives cannot defeat rights. But they are not empty either. Courts use them to read the law and to uphold State action that serves them. A reservation or scholarship law finds support in Article 46, even though the article cannot force it.
- Directives guide the State; rights bind the State.
- Minerva Mills 1980: balance between the two is basic structure.
- Laws that serve Article 46 are on firm constitutional ground.
True or False: In Minerva Mills the Supreme Court held that Directive Principles always override Fundamental Rights.
6How has this topic been asked in exams?
6.1 What did the exams ask?
UPSC 2020: Part IV provisions
The question gave three statements on Part IV. One said these provisions are enforceable by courts. Another said they are not. A third said they influence lawmaking. The answer is “2 and 3 only”. This is the base idea behind Article 46. See Q18 in the full paper.
UPSC 2015: What do Directive Principles do?
The question asked about two statements. One said Directive Principles spell out socio-economic democracy. The other said no court can enforce them. Both are correct, so the answer is “both 1 and 2”. See Q7 in the full paper.
CAPF (AC) 2019: Which statement is NOT correct?
One option claimed that Directive Principles take precedence over Fundamental Rights if the two clash. That was the wrong statement. The other options were correct: the State must follow directives, and directives are not enforceable. See Q48 in the full paper.
6.2 What is the exam angle?
- Trap: Article 46 is a Fundamental Right. It is a Directive Principle.
- Trap: Directives override rights. The Court says they must be balanced.
- Fact: Article 46 covers SCs, STs and other weaker sections.
- Fact: Champakam Dorairajan 1951 led to the First Amendment and Article 15(4).
- Fact: Article 338 (SC commission), Article 338A (ST commission).
- Method: Goal in Part IV; tools in Part III.
MCQ on Article 46: Weaker Sections
Answered 0 of 3 checks.
Share your thoughts