The CAG and Finance Commission

The CAG audits how public money is spent, while the Finance Commission decides how tax revenue is shared. Both are essential checks on government finances.

MCQquestion.com

Polity0058 · Indian Polity & Constitution

The CAG & Finance Commission

Two distinct pillars of India’s fiscal accountability

CAG removal

Like a JudgeSupreme Court procedure

Finance Commission

Every 5 yearsUnder Article 280

CAG resignation goes to

The PresidentWritten letter

The CAG

• Audits the Consolidated Fund, Contingency Fund, and Public Accounts.
• Removable only like a Supreme Court Judge.
• Cannot hold further government office after leaving.
• Jurisdiction is co-extensive with the Union’s own executive power.

Finance Commission

• Constituted under Article 280, every five years.
• Decides how tax revenue is shared between Union and States.
• Has a Chairman and members, with the number fixed by Parliament.
• Periodic reconstitution lets the revenue formula adapt over time.

Two Complementary Pillars

Together, the CAG and Finance Commission form two distinct but complementary pillars of India’s fiscal accountability architecture.

MCQquestion.com

Download as image

Must Know

• The Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) audits expenditure from the Consolidated Fund, Contingency Fund, and Public Accounts.
• The CAG can be removed through the same procedure used for removing a Supreme Court Judge.
• The CAG’s role narrowed after accounting was formally separated from auditing, sharpening its focus specifically on audit functions.
• The Finance Commission, constituted under Article 280 every five years, decides how tax revenue is shared between the Union and States.
• The Finance Commission consists of a Chairman and additional members, with the exact number fixed by Parliament.

Good to Know

• If the CAG wishes to resign, the resignation letter must be addressed to the President.
• After ceasing to hold office, a former CAG is not eligible for further government office, protecting the institution’s independence.
• The CAG’s jurisdiction is described as co-extensive with the Union’s own executive power, reflecting its comprehensive audit reach.

Test Yourself

Please wait…

1. Which Article of the Constitution prescribes the duties and powers of the Comptroller and Auditor General of India?

Article 146

Article 147

Article 148

Article 149

 Loading…

 

Great to Know

• The CAG’s protections against removal and re-employment mirror judicial safeguards, reflecting how seriously the Constitution treats financial oversight independence.
• The Finance Commission’s periodic reconstitution allows India’s revenue-sharing formula to adapt to changing economic conditions across States over time.
• Together, the CAG and Finance Commission form two distinct but complementary pillars of India’s fiscal accountability architecture.
• Not all Union-State revenue sharing runs through the Finance Commission, though. Inter-State GST (IGST) is apportioned separately, under Article 269A. In 2019, the CAG itself flagged ₹13,944 crore in IGST left unapportioned, sitting in the Consolidated Fund of India instead of reaching the States.
• For a dedicated deep dive into the Finance Commission itself, see Polity0341 — The Finance Commission of India.